Largest Real Estate Risk

👋👋 Good morning real estate watchers! Today, we are going to talk about...

  1. Home insurance in Florida now costs as much as a college tuition. And much like a college degree, you still might end up with nothing but a pile of debt and a crushing sense of regret.

  2. Homeownership now comes with the same interest rate as your first credit card, except that instead of a free T-shirt, you get a 30-year commitment to financial ruin.

  3. Turns out, the best real estate investment isn’t beachfront property—it’s just being within shouting distance of Pennsylvania Avenue.

Let’s go!

TOP STORY

INSURANCE

If the three most important words in real estate are "location, location, location," then the fourth is quickly becoming "insurance." And not in a good way.

For years, real estate investors and homeowners alike have operated under a set of predictable risks: interest rate fluctuations, local economic shifts, and the occasional housing bubble. But today, one risk is towering over the rest, reshaping the market from Florida to California—climate-driven insurance chaos.

Climate Risk is No Longer Hypothetical

Rising insurance costs and increasing instances of catastrophic climate events are beginning to rewrite the real estate playbook. Natural disasters—once considered "low probability, high impact" events—are now hitting with alarming regularity.

A study by First Street Foundation found that 39 million homes nationwide are at significant risk of climate-related disasters, including hurricanes, wildfires, floods, and extreme heat. And while some homeowners might still brush off climate change as a future problem, their insurance bills say otherwise.

Sticker Shock: Homeowners Insurance Goes Vertical

The national average for home insurance premiums surged to nearly $2,400 in 2023, according to the Insurance Information Institute. But in high-risk states like Florida, where insurers are fleeing the market, premiums have skyrocketed to an eye-watering $11,000 per year—if you can find coverage at all.

Big-name insurers such as State Farm and Allstate have pulled out of entire states, including California, citing "uninsurable" risks. Their departure leaves homeowners at the mercy of state-backed insurance pools, which often come with limited coverage and rising rates.

And homeowners aren't alone in their concerns. Investors, banks, and developers are recalibrating risk models, factoring in a new reality where insurance is no longer a predictable line item but a volatile and sometimes unavailable necessity.

Who Foots the Bill?

With private insurers retreating from the riskiest regions, policymakers are scrambling for solutions. In Florida, where hurricanes have made the insurance market a financial sinkhole, Representative Jared Moskowitz has proposed a national catastrophic insurance fund. The idea is to spread the risk nationwide so homeowners in at-risk states aren’t the only ones absorbing the financial blow.

"Even if my bill doesn’t move or go anywhere, Congress has to start realizing that we have to amortize the risk," Moskowitz told Fox News. "It can't just be on one state or two states to deal with this."

The proposal is sure to be controversial. Critics argue that it’s essentially a national subsidy for people choosing to live in high-risk areas. Supporters counter that without some form of intervention, entire housing markets could collapse, leaving millions of homeowners without coverage or worse—unable to sell their homes.

Will This Change Where Americans Live?

Despite rising insurance costs, Americans continue to flock to the South, with Florida and Texas leading the way. But will that trend hold if homeownership costs spiral out of control?

A Zillow analysis found that climate risk is starting to impact home values. In areas with frequent natural disasters, appreciation rates are slowing compared to lower-risk regions. Buyers are factoring in not just the mortgage and taxes but also the unpredictability of future insurance costs.

Homeowners are also beginning to forego insurance altogether—12% of U.S. homeowners don’t carry any coverage, according to the Wall Street Journal. That number is expected to climb as costs rise, leaving millions vulnerable to financial ruin if disaster strikes.

How to Protect Yourself (and Your Portfolio)

For those looking to mitigate risk, there are a few strategies that can help:

  1. Geographic Diversification – Real estate investors should spread their assets across multiple regions, balancing high-growth, high-risk markets with safer inland properties.

  2. Risk-Based Pricing Awareness – Buyers should research not just property values but also long-term insurance trends and local disaster histories before making a purchase.

  3. Retrofitting and Resilience – Homes built or upgraded with fire-resistant materials, flood barriers, and hurricane-proof windows may qualify for insurance discounts, providing a layer of financial protection.

  4. Government and Private Partnerships – Stay informed about state-backed insurance programs, catastrophe bonds, and legislative efforts that could impact long-term affordability.

The Bottom Line

The housing market has long operated under the assumption that insurance is just a given—an unavoidable but predictable cost. That assumption no longer holds.

With climate risks driving up costs and reshaping migration patterns, homeowners, investors, and policymakers alike face a future in which the biggest risk in real estate isn’t just location—it’s whether one can afford to stay insured at all.

If you think that's bad, just wait until the next "once-in-a-century" storm hits—probably sometime next summer.

SNIPPETS

1️⃣ Wildfire Rental Rodeo: The median monthly housing payment has reached $2,686, driven by a 7.04% mortgage rate and a 5% year-over-year home price increase, while pending home sales have declined 10.1% annually. The Los Angeles area is experiencing a unique phenomenon where wildfires have destroyed approximately 17% of homes within certain perimeters, causing a significant surge in rental demand, with online rental listing views nearly doubling compared to the previous year. Real estate professionals are witnessing an unprecedented rental market scramble, with properties receiving multiple offers within hours, underscoring the complex interplay between natural disasters, housing inventory, and market volatility. (Redfin)

2️⃣ Mortgage Mayhem: 30-year mortgage rates breached the 7% threshold this week, climbing 11 basis points to 7.04%, marking the highest level since May 2024, according to Freddie Mac's latest data. While December's robust jobs report and initial inflation concerns pushed rates upward, nuanced inflation data suggests potential relief, with shelter and core inflation showing signs of moderation. Industry experts anticipate potential rate stabilization in late January, with the new administration, and early February labor data poised to introduce market volatility that could potentially nudge rates lower, offering a glimmer of hope for homebuyers navigating the complex real estate landscape. (Realtor.com)

3️⃣ Homes Gone Wild: Single-family homes are commanding an unprecedented premium over traditional apartments, with Zillow's latest data revealing a staggering 20% price differential—the largest gap ever recorded. The December 2024 rental market analysis exposes a dramatic landscape where single-family rental homes average $2,174 monthly, representing a robust 4.4% annual increase and a jaw-dropping 40.6% surge since the pandemic's onset, compared to apartment rents averaging $1,812, which have climbed 2.4% year-over-year. (HW)

4️⃣ Rooms Galore! In a landmark year for U.S. hospitality infrastructure, the hotel construction pipeline surged to an unprecedented 6,378 projects totaling 746,986 rooms in 2024, representing a robust 7-8% year-over-year expansion, according to Lodging Econometrics' latest industry report. Upper-midscale hotels dominated the landscape with 2,354 projects and 227,845 rooms, while the sector witnessed significant momentum in new project announcements, with 459 fresh developments adding 58,123 rooms to the pipeline. The national hotel supply is projected to incrementally expand, with forecasts indicating 1.2% growth in 2024, escalating to a 1.5% increase in 2025 and a promising 1.7% surge in 2026, underpinned by 730 and 904 new hotel openings, respectively. (HNR)

5️⃣ Home Sales Hibernate: In a stark testament to the ongoing housing market challenges, existing-home sales in 2024 plummeted to the lowest level since 1995, marking the second consecutive year of anemic market activity primarily driven by persistently high mortgage rates hovering between 6-8%. Despite the Federal Reserve's modest rate cuts, the housing landscape remains constrained by affordability issues, with the national median existing-home price reaching $404,400 in December—a 6% year-over-year increase—while total sales dropped 0.7% to 4.06 million units. (WSJ)

6️⃣ CRE's Bumpy Recovery: In a recent MSCI report analyzing commercial real estate (CRE) trends for 2025, industry experts have identified a fragile recovery landscape marked by significant financial challenges, with approximately $500 billion in loans facing potential valuation distress. Approximately 14% of maturing loans could be classified as "underwater" if assessed at current Q3 2024 price levels, signaling persistent market volatility, particularly in aging industrial sectors where assets constructed before 2010 suffer from structural obsolescence and fundamental operational limitations. (Globe St)

7️⃣ Wealth Meets Pennsylvania Ave: Recent data reveals a significant surge in high-end property transactions in Washington DC directly correlated with the Trump administration's return, with Bright MLS reporting 87 home sales above $5 million in 2024, compared to just 16 in 2016. Wealthy political appointees, tech entrepreneurs, and business leaders are aggressively acquiring multimillion-dollar properties in the capital and surrounding areas, driving median luxury sale prices up 42% from Q4 2019 to $2.15 million in Q4 2024. Local real estate agents, drawing from decades of experience, attribute this phenomenon to a combination of economic confidence, limited inventory, and a strategic desire to be in proximity to political power, with approximately 20% of deals above $5 million since November tied directly to the new administration. (Realtor.com)

Reply

or to participate.